Newsletter

Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!

Opinion

Letters to The Mag – Newcastle United fans with their say

28 Aug 2024 - 11:50

The opinions continue to flow into The Mag, as Newcastle United fans debate the various issues affecting our club.

Whether it is events on or off the pitch, always plenty to talk about.

The 2024/25 Premier League season fast approaching, just over three weeks away now.

Newcastle United fans with the latest collection of opinions below, plus sometimes the odd visitor from elsewhere…

Contributions are sometimes too brief to make up into a full article and so we have gathered up a number of recent comments sent in, relating to issues at Newcastle United (if you would like to send anything in, long or short, then contribute@themag.co.uk is the place):

Dear Mag,

Thoughts from New Zealand.

Willock replacing Longstaff and Barnes replacing Murphy.

Ideal team with all available and present : Pope, Livramento, Schar, Botman, Trippier, Willock, Bruno, Tonali, Gordon, Isak, Barnes

Thoughts?

Cheers Andy

Dear Mag,

I’m ‘knocking on’ eighty years old, born and bred in Byker but now living in the Peak District 150 miles from St James Park.

I’m a fan; always have been, always will be.

Although I haven’t seen the team live since the Souness era, I reckon I’ve paid my dues by pushing through the turnstiles over 1,300 times since my first Jackie Milburn match in 1952 .

I now get my Toon Army fix from my armchair through TV and – though far from being a keyboard warrior – that glorious new thing called social media… marvellous.

Keep up the good work lads.

I reckon there are tens of thousands of ‘dinosaur mags’ just like me enjoying your contributions on The Mag.

David Bell

Dear Mag,

Enough is enough….

Marc Guehi is now cup tied….

We’ll never find out the truth about this incredibly dragged out affair but I’m completely done with it.

Guehi is NOT WORTH £70M and I would not be surprised if we had walked away from this deal a while ago, with the gutter press just keeping the story going as clickbait.

Paul Mitchell has not got off to a good start at all either way this turns out…

If Guehi does sign – we’ve paid way too much and Guehi will have a HUGE amount of pressure to live up to his massive purchase price – the first mistake he makes will be “confirmation that he’s not worth it” for some fans and that Palace will have well and truly pulled our pants down – if it goes badly it could seriously affect his confidence…if he does sign, let’s hope can cope with things..

If Guehi does not sign, it will be seen as a huge failure on Mitchell’s part (despite how Palace have behaved – which I suspect has been difficult with “consistently changing goalposts”).

We now have just THREE DAYS LEFT to get a central defender AND a right winger who can at least pose a threat…

It will be nothing short of scandalous incompetence if we manage neither…

On a different note, I read today that a £70m bid was almost accepted by us for PSR reasons for Anthony Gordon to Liverpool but was dropped at the last minute when we sold Anderson and Minteh…. So no surprise that he’s a “bit miffed“ that we almost sold our player of the season last year…let’s hope he can understand and get over it…it’s clearly done his head in – he’s not the same player.

I feel really sorry for Eddie – circumstances are definitely against him at the moment – I hope he doesn’t think that he’s on his own (although he might feel like it at the moment).

Let’s hope we get past Forest…

Daz

Dear Mag,

Newcastle obviously have at least £65 million burning a hole in their pocket to spend on new players this window, given the interest and bids put in for Marc Guehi.

To my mind, we have certainly played the long game with Crystal Palace on this one and to not follow it through at this very late stage in the window would be crazy, given the fact we need a right sided centre half as a minimum requirement.

It seems this window is going to end just like the PSR scramble at the end of June and if we don’t add at least two players, it very much feels like we will have in fact weakened our squad, letting two young very good players leave the club.

Kevin V

Dear Mag,

He’s from Essex, so I am wondering if Darren Eales is nicknamed ‘Jellied’.

Alex Stokoe

Dear Mag,

I am seeing a lot of hysteria from certain Newcastle fans.

They need to calm down.

Far too early to be judging this season after two matches AND four points from a possible six!

Those four points coming from a full on battling 10 men against Southampton, then an in and out, what I would call average away performance at Bournemouth. Not great, not terrible. We created the best chances and Bournemouth keeper man of the match, making at least three top saves.

I can’t really understand how this was a terrible start to the season.

Answers on a postcard.

Some pretty clueless people as well with the Minteh and Anderson sales. With them wondering why we haven’t spent this money on new signings?

Those sales were instead of having to sell a first choice key player and were needed to balance the books/PSR after buying the likes of Bruno, Isak, Tonali, Botman, Livramento, Pope, Trippier, Willock, Barnes, Hall, Burn, Targett and Gordon in this three year PSR period (1 July 2021 to 30 June 2024).

Bri Milburn

Share

If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to contribute@themag.co.uk

Have your say

© 2026 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks