Very surprising results after asked Newcastle fans should supporters be allowed into stadiums?
The question we asked on Thursday was: ‘Should Newcastle United fans and other supporters be allowed into stadiums?’
A big debate going on, as football fans see the Government allowing certain other areas able to operate with reduced capacities, but not football.
Newcastle United have given their support to a new petition calling for fans to be allowed back into matches.
The petition (view and sign here) was launched on Tuesday and has already gained over 190,000 signatures (as at 8am on Friday 9 October 2020), this has already passed the 100,000 mark whereby Parliament has to now consider the matter for debate. However, obviously the more signatures, the stronger the message is that football fans do indeed see this as something that is fair and can be done safely.
The Petition states:
‘Allow football fans to attend matches at all levels
Football is a powerful tool of which allows a range of benefits such as employment, and other important aspects of life. Football can be associated with passion, emotion, excitement and dedication across the community. With Fans attending football games a range of economic benefits are there too.
Due to the current issues around COVID places such as France and Germany now allow a percentage of fans to return to football games. I ask for the support of this petition as I fear that smaller clubs in particular will go out of business leading to a devastating effect on people. This petition is to ask the government to reconsider their judgement on not letting football fans back into the stadiums and reconsider doing this with the right safety measures in place surrounding the COVID-19.’
Tuesday also brought an ‘Open letter to fans on safe return to stadiums’ (see below), which was published by the football authorities, including the Premier League.
They were one of four co-signatories to the letter (read below), Richard Masters signing it off on behalf of the Premier League, along with David Baldwin (EFL Chief Executive), Mark Bullingham (FA Chief Executive) and Kelly Simmons (FA Director of Women’s Professional Game).
The open letter was to tell fans that working together, the Premier League and their co-signatories are all going to continue to push for a return of football fans to stadiums.
They make the point: ‘It is positive progress that major arts and music venues have been told they can run socially-distanced events indoors. And now football should be allowed to do the same – in highly regulated and stewarded outdoor environments.’ It was recently announced that the Royal Albert Hall for example is being allowed to run events with up to 3,000 attending, in a venue that holds around 5,500 people.
In Germany last weekend, amongst the clubs with fans inside the stadium, you had Borussia Dortmund with 11,500 inside the stadium.
On Wednesday night Fabian Schar played for Switzerland at home to Croatia and 5,000 allowed into the stadium by the local authorities and UEFA, limited to 30% of capacity.
Jamal Lewis played in front of fans last night, with 2,000 allowed into Bosnia v Northern Ireland in Sarajevo, whilst 600 will be allowed into Northern Ireland’s match at home to Austria on Sunday.
So what did Newcastle United fans think though?
Should supporters be allowed back into St James Park and other stadium in England, albeit with a reduced capacity?
I must admit that I was amazed by the result.
Thanks to all who voted:
32% Yes – Fans should be allowed into stadiums with a reduced capacity.
68% No – Fans shouldn’t be allowed in at this moment in time.
To be honest, I would have guessed the voting would have been exactly the opposite, with roughly two thirds thinking supporters should be allowed back in now.
Turns out the comments on social media were reflective of the general mood for once.
The ‘Open letter to fans on safe return to stadiums’ published 6 October 2020:
The Premier League, EFL, The FA, Women’s Super League and Women’s Championship want to assure all fans that together we are fully committed to your safe return to football grounds as soon as possible.
The health of the nation remains our overriding priority, and for many months we have been working with experts to make our grounds as safe as, if not safer than, any other public activity currently allowed. And we are consulting with the Football Supporters’ Association to keep supporters updated every step of the way.
We know attendance at matches can play a positive role in people’s lives during these challenging times. And the past few months have shown how clubs can still feel the support of their fans.
Even when you have been unable to get together, you and your clubs have found ways to make a difference in your communities, with clubs delivering food parcels, taking part in phone calls and online conversations with fans, the elderly and vulnerable and moving services and programmes online to make a difference in unprecedented and challenging circumstances.
But we all know football is not the same without fans. Every player and manager is missing the direct connection with you and the impact that you have on our games.
Successful test events
With the EFL, Premier League, Women’s Super League and Women’s Championship already staging 11 successful test events recently, we have demonstrated that we can deliver matches safely. The sooner we can return, the sooner we can reunite communities and support local jobs, livelihoods, regional businesses and also the national economy.
We will continue to urge Government to allow us to return fans safely to stadiums. It is positive progress that major arts and music venues have been told they can run socially-distanced events indoors. And now football should be allowed to do the same – in highly regulated and stewarded outdoor environments.
Additionally, representatives from football are active members of the Government’s Sports Technology and Innovation Group, as well as being involved with their ‘Moonshot’ mass-testing project to open up the economy. And in light of the postponement of test events we will intensify our efforts to pioneer new approaches – working with epidemiologists, scientists and medical experts in areas such as public health, clinical processes and occupational hygiene. This will make sure stadiums are COVID-safe by considering best-practice screening and hygiene methods to ensure that fans and the general public will be safe and drive the Government’s sporting plans to move faster.
Reducing risk of transmission
Stadium environments can be modified and carefully managed. Measures could include screening spectators before they enter the ground, installing temperature checks, requiring masks to be worn, one-way systems and providing a code of conduct for all those attending on a matchday. This will all be bolstered by deep-cleaning practices to help further reduce the risk of virus transmission.
Clubs want to be pro-active on this matter and are willing to consider measures both in the stadium and on the approach that will allay any concerns as to fans’ safety. From a travel perspective, clubs will work closely with experts and local authorities to model solutions relevant for each stadium to ease pressure on public transport, while extra parking facilities could be available so a greater proportion of you can travel by private car or bicycle.
We are determined to identify a path forward with Government. We need clarity for our clubs and for you as supporters as to what the roadmap for change in this area looks like. We all know why caution is needed, and we ask Government for consistency in their policy so sport is treated as fairly as other activities currently allowed to welcome spectators.
So, we will continue to urge the relevant authorities to let us, together, use innovative ways to bring fans safely back into football grounds, starting with a return of the test event programme. If we do so, then the benefits will be felt not just by fans but throughout society and the economy.
Richard Masters, Premier League Chief Executive
David Baldwin, EFL Chief Executive
Mark Bullingham, FA Chief Executive
Kelly Simmons, FA Director of Women’s Professional Game
If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]