Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!


Was this four years ahead of its time…? ‘Why low prices will ruin football’

2 years ago

Bearing in mind what is happening in the Premier League at the moment, especially at Newcastle United, I was interested to come across this article from four, almost five, years ago.

It was written by Chris Holt for The Mag and published on 26 April 2015 (read it below).

The article was prompted in particular, by West Ham announcing details ahead of their planned move to the Olympic Stadium.

Moving way from the Boleyn Ground/Upton Park wasn’t popular with many/most West Ham fans and they would have 20,000 or so extra seats to sell.

Unlike Mike Ashley this week, the Hammers weren’t actually giving season tickets away, but they were massively dropping their prices.

The Hammers’ cheapest season ticket was to more than half in price from £620 to £289 when they moved stadiums for the 2016/17 season.

In his article, Chris Holt made the case that cheaper (free now in the case of Mike Ashley) tickets would decrease the value/power of fans with club owners, if it went too far.

If you look at West Ham, they are a club who claim they are sold out week in week out and indeed according to their official attendances have less unsold seats than any other club this season.

Yet at the same time, when you see them at home on the TV there are always loads of empty seats, anywhere between five and ten thousand usually, from what I have seen.

Reducing ticket prices for so many fans to around £15 per game for season ticket holders, means it is far easier for many of them clearly, to think they’ll miss a match here and there, or even on a regular basis, apart from more glamorous games.

Man City are another, they claim full houses and yet they have loads of empty seats every match bar the most glamorous ones, with a vastly increased capacity they made the same decision as the Hammers, so many season tickets at similarly rock bottom prices.

What happens at Newcastle becomes very interesting now, as unless something miraculous happens (Ashley selling up), just how difficult will it be to sell NUFC tickets after giving away 10,000 season tickets and with the long-term cheaper price season ticket deals set to end shortly for around 20,000 Newcastle fans?

‘Why low prices will ruin football’ by Chris Holt – First published on 26 April 2015:

The audiences you see on television don’t pay for tickets to those shows.  The reason for that is the vast majority of shows are so bad that nobody would pay to go and watch them.

However, the BBC and ITV are selling a product to a wider audience than that.  They want the viewing public at home to be fooled into believing that what they are watching is of some value.  So there are websites where the public can apply for free tickets to be herded into shows and told when to laugh and when to cheer and applaud but never to boo or to express any dissatisfaction.

It’s always funny to me when the facade slips and a show cuts back to the audience in silence for a beat, before they’re reminded of their job and start whooping and hollering.  Big brother do that better than anyone.  100 people stood silently miserable in a cold damp car park at half ten on a Friday night suddenly flare up like they all won the lottery.  What are they cheering?  The end of the adverts?  No, that’s the bargain, you get free tickets, you see Davina McCall, you do as you’re told and legitimise the show.

The news that West Ham are slashing season ticket prices in their new stadium tells us that Premier League football is heading the same way.  When the new TV deal begins in 2016 their cheapest season ticket will more than half in price from £620 to £289, from £32 a game to £15.  What were once supporters are now only fans.  The finance they provide a club is no longer of any significance to the club’s survival.  Like TV shows, clubs are not beholden to the audience on location, but to the viewers at home.

Newcastle are in the same boat as West Ham and a dozen other clubs.  Mike Ashley has made a song and dance about freezing ticket prices for those that commit for 10 years, but in reality those that didn’t commit long-term have rarely seen an increase anyway.

In the Gallowgate and Leazes ends season tickets are already £24 less than they were 3 years ago.  Season tickets are slowly following the trend of single tickets and getting cheaper rather than more expensive.  Why, if the league is more popular than ever?  It’s there for all to see  in the TV show model.

Like most TV shows, clubs outside of the top 6 or 7 are not worth watching.  They are not looking to thrill, to entertain, to compete, to win.  These are clubs jostling with each other just to survive, set up not to lose games primarily and if they scrape the odd win here and there, it’s enough.

Without actually striving to captivate a crowd, other methods have to be used to attract people and have them make some noise. The home audience will not stand for quiet empty stadiums.  Some clubs have started to play music after a goal, just like the “laugh” card being held up on the set of a TV show and in lieu of the roar that would have greeted a goal in years gone by.

And like TV shows, clubs can’t attract crowds to this sporting capitulation while charging even reasonable ticket prices.  Prices will continue to go down at clubs in line with the quality of product on display. It’s the only way of ensuring seats remain populated on camera to give the appearance of a product worth paying for.

Judging by the West Ham announcement, Premier League football could be cheaper to watch in person than Championship football from 2016.  If those in the second tier have to drop their prices further, how much lower can League one and two clubs go while still being able to employ professional players?

As supporters we demand cheaper tickets, but care needs to be taken for the wider good of the game to ensure that the majority of tickets are sold for a fair price, not given away like West Ham are tending towards and not inordinate as visitors to Arsenal, Chelsea and Manchester City have seen for themselves.

The debasement of what it is to be a supporter of a club in the Premier League has ramifications throughout the game in England and will inevitably lead to professional clubs without either TV riches or matchday income becoming unsustainable.

It is vital that we don’t allow ourselves to be bought by TV money like the owners of our clubs already have, we must make our dissatisfaction heard, we must ensure that supporters have representation in the boardroom of every club so that the entire fanbase is not devalued to the point of becoming Saturday Night Takeaway style automatons.

#standuptoashley #20plenty

You can also keep in touch with all of Chris Holt’s blogs via NUFC Miscommunication and NUFC-Ashlies Blogspot


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2021 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks