Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!


Strange fans choice of Newcastle team v Crystal Palace

10 months ago

We asked fans the question, which 11 players would you pick in your Newcastle team v Crystal Palace?

We put together a list of the 21 players who looked as though they could potentially be selected for this game.

A win today would guarantee a place in the top half of the Premier League at Christmas.

On Friday morning, Steve Bruce said that as well as Lascelles and Ritchie and Saint-Maximin missing.

Also definitely ruled out of this Palace game are Ciaran Clark and Ki Sung-yeung.

As for Shelvey and Almiron, Steve Bruce indicated that if they came through training on Friday, they would be available today.

Dubravka yet again getting what is regularly becoming 100% support and leading the way.

Then four other players having the support of 92% or more of fans.

Schar (97%), Almiron (93%), Shelvey (93%) and Willems (92%).

Then making it up to eight players we have Fernandez (86%), Carroll (85%) and Hayden (84%).

Then nine and ten are Manquillo (65%) earning his place ahead of Yedlin (32%) and Dummett (64%).

Then making up the final piece of this strange team selection, Lejeune (48%) is just ahead of Sean Longstaff (42%) and Joelinton (42%).

Now I know that Newcastle’s strength lies in defence but this is taking it a bit far…

I make it that we have Dubravka and six defenders (Fernandez, Lejeune, Schar, Dummett, Manquillo and Willems.

Then two central midfielders (Shelvey and Hayden) and two attacking players (Carroll and Almiron).

If putting these into some kind of formation, I suppose you would have to move Willems forward as a midfielder (or Schar possibly), with Almiron behind Carroll.

Not exactly a massive vote of support for our striking options, Gayle only getting 33% support as well, Muto a minuscule 5%.

This is how the Newcastle team v Crystal Palace looks with a suggested formation based on the fan votes, with then the percentage votes rounded up/down to nearest whole number for each of the 21 players.

100% Dubravka

97% Schar

93% Almiron

93% Shelvey

92% Willems

86% Fernandez

85% Carroll

84% Hayden

65% Manquillo

64% Dummett

48% Lejeune

42% Sean Longstaff

42% Joelinton

33% Gayle

32% Yedlin

28% Atsu

15% Matty Longstaff

5% Muto

2% Krafth

0% Elliot

0% Darlow


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2020 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks