Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!

Transfer Rumours

Feeble ‘Exclusive’ claims Newcastle United set to bid for Everton star

2 years ago

Rafa Benitez wants to sign James McCarthy according to an ‘exclusive’ on Tuesday night.

Teamtalk claim that the Spaniard is keen to bring in the Everton midfielder this summer, if he extends his stay at St James Park.

Regardless of Rafa’s situation, Newcastle will almost certainly need to bring in at least one or two midfielders, with Mohamed Diame, Isaac Hayden and Jonjo Shelvey looking very likely to move out.

Whether this would equal interest in James McCarthy is another matter.

Newcastle United have actually been linked with the (now) 28 year old a number of times (see below).

In January 2017 it was claimed Rafa/Newcastle had a £16m offer turned down by Everton, all a little bit dubious as in that mid-season window in the promotion season, Mike Ashley blocked the manager from even bringing in any loan signings.

Then in advance of the summer 2017 transfer window, it was claimed that Newcastle were now willing to pay £20m for James McCarthy, maybe even more difficult to believe as that window £10m Jacob Murpy was the biggest transfer allowed by the NUFC owner.

Teamtalk have ran the ‘exclusive’ and they have a shocking record with their NUFC transfer exclusives.

Although to be fair, in some ways you could see this as a classic Mike Ashley signing. In that it would likely be a modest transfer fee but a massive gamble, as James McCarthy has had serious injury issues and only started 10 Premier League games in the past three seasons. his only PL action last season was 14 minutes as a sub.

I would be sceptical that there is any real Newcastle interest but if there was, I would assume it would be more so if Rafa Benitez leaves, than if he stays.

The Teamtalk ‘exclusive’;

‘EXCLUSIVE: Benitez wants Everton ace if he extends Newcastle stay

Rafa Benitez is ready to make a move for an Everton midfielder, if he remains at Newcastle this summer, we can reveal.

Benitez is braced to lose midfielders Jonjo Shelvey and Isaac Hayden this summer, but he feels that Republic of Ireland and Everton ace James McCarthy could help cover their loss.

McCarthy is back to full fitness after an injury-ridden 18 months on Merseyside and is looking to leave Everton, with Marco Silva not seeing him as part of his long-term plans at Goodison Park.’

The Mag – 7 May 2017:

Just before the January transfer window closed, it was reported that Newcastle had allegedly had a £16m offer for James McCarthy turned down.

It was claimed that Everton Chairman Bill Kenwright told Newcastle that the player wouldn’t be joining them, even though he was no longer a first team regular.

The Mail ran the story and whilst the Magpies could have done with with extra quality in the middle of the pitch to see this season/promotion out, it is difficult to believe that they were willing to pay £16m for it, or indeed any sizeable transfer fee, especially as the constant message that month was that only loan deals, if anything, would potentially happen.

Sunday morning has brought this James McCarthy supposed interest around again and once more it is The Mail who are running it.

This time they claim that if Rafa Benitez is given the transfer budget he wants from Mike Ashley, the Newcastle Manager is supposedly willing to pay £20m to bring McCarthy to St James Park. With the likes of Stoke’s Ryan Shawcross, Fulham’s Tom Cairney, and Southampton’s Jay Rodriguez also claimed to be on the United boss’ shopping list.

James McCarthy signed four ago for Everton and is a decent player but spending that kind of money on a midfielder who doesn’t score or create goals would be a surprise.

In these four years on Merseyside since moving for £13m from Wigan, McCarthy has only scored six Premier League goals and got seven assists.

Predictably, one of his five goals came against Newcastle, scoring the first one in a 3-0 win in March 2015 – the game when Coloccini was sent off.

The scousers have signed Schneiderlin from Manchester United, Besic is coming back from injury, teenager Tom Davies has emerged as yet another potential star from their production line, so no surprise if Everton would sell James McCarthy if the money was right – especially as Ronald Koeman is also reported to be looking to bring in another midfielder this summer.

He has only started seven Premier League matches this season and hasn’t started any in over three months, making a few sub appearances in late February/early March.

However, as well as indifferent form this season, James McCarthy has had recurring hamstring complaints this campaign and is once again out injured – not featuring in the 18 man squad that lost 1-0 at Swansea yesterday.

Whether or not Rafa Benitez sees the Everton player as a wanted man, it is a reminder of the kind of prices that will be needed to be paid, if Newcastle are to land players this summer with any kind of proven Premier League pedigree.


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2020 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks