Manchester United fans had plenty to say before Wednesday night’s match at St James Park and even more so afterwards.

Hoping for a fourth win in a row under new boss Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, their views pre-match ranged from expecting an easy three points and boost to the goal difference, to those expecting it to be the toughest test yet under the new manager.

Following the game, the views were equally diverse.

You have some Manchester United fans thinking it was a great victory, whilst others thought it was a bit of a disappointment to win by only two.

Interesting also to hear what they say about Newcastle United.

Can’t really disagree with them when they complain about Shelvey’s ‘tackle’ on Pogba, it was a stupid and reckless challenge which could have been most damaging for his own team, if he’d picked up a three match ban – especially with Ki away until February.

On the wider issues for NUFC, we had everything from pure hatred to a lot of sympathy for our existence under Mike Ashley.

Interesting reading below.

Manchester United fans commenting on their top Red Cafe message board:


Newcastle are dire though they are always up for it v us and we’ve made a right mess of our last few visits there. Have to win though and we will.’

‘Imagine how grim this fixture would have been if it was Mourinho versus Benitez? would have been beyond awful.

It feels great that we can look forward to football again.’

‘Rondon is going to have a fun time against our defenders.. But if our attackers turn up, we should easily outscore them.’

‘These Geordies always have a tendency to turn up against us especially at St James’ Park.

If we play the same way we have done then we will get the win. Confidence is sky high at the club which is great to see.’

‘Should be another 1-3 or 1-4 win.’

‘First real test for Ole. I think we’ll struggle particularly with Newcastle having an extra day’s rest. Probably a draw.’

Benitez will duly park the bus. It’ll be a challenge to break them down and at the same time not get done on the counter.’

‘Newcastle are the 2nd worst home side in the league this year. have dropped 23 points out of 30, -8 GD. Worst is Huddersfield with 25 points dropped at home

Have won 1 in their last 7. 1-0 away to Huddersfield.’

‘Got to get control and score early to calm that irritating ground down.’

‘This will be Solskjaer’s biggest test so far, trying to break down the Rafabus and not getting caught on the counter.’

‘Newcastle goal difference -12, I think we should be looking to increase that, substantially.’

‘Absolutely hate Newcastle. Hope they get relegated soon. To them every game against United is a cup final. They will step up against us and bend over for other teams.’

‘I’m up in the North East and if I survive New Years Eve i’m going to this, and to be honest i’m more concerned about getting the last no.47 bus back into deepest darkest Gateshead after the match and keeping my gob shut, than the match itself.

Comfortable 0-2 or 1-3 win.’

‘We’ll win by 6 goals.’

‘Isn’t it nice knowing that we have a game against a team like Newcastle and expecting that we will at least try to kick their teeth in rather than expecting to go 1-0 before losing interest for the rest of the game and conceding a sloppy late goal.’

‘Newcastle are atrocious we should be winning this but they’ll play defensive so we may have to be patient.’

‘This will be a test because Rafa don’t like no Man United. BUT WE WIN.’

‘Make no mistake, they will be up for it.’

‘Another bunch of Game Raising C’s.

2 -2.’

‘That prick Benitez threw the game v the Scousers last week with his team selection and tactics but he’ll have them primed for us on Wednesday no doubt, the absolute weapon.’


‘Feck off Newcastle, you lost your cup final small timers.’

‘Newcastle surprisingly decent today.’

‘Rafa side will always be stronger than the sum of his parts.

How he and the Newcastle fans must pray for new owners to invest in the club.’

‘That’s a hard fought, honest and contested clean sheet victory. Resolve and character throughout the back and front that haven’t seen too many times before today.’

‘Very pleased Ole got his clean sheet. Could’ve been 3 or 4 nil in the end.’

‘Finally a good result in Geordie land.’

‘Lindelof MOTM by some distance.

‘Best game to date, was flawless. Even won a majority of the headers against Rondon!’

‘Deserved victory, but the worst of our 4 performances under Solskjaer.

A bit of fatigue was probably at play, but I think the main issue today was the team selection that was utterly disjointed and made Newcastle’s job far easier.’

‘Hard fought game. They didn’t have gold opportunities. I think we were pretty careless with our final balls having carved them open a few times especially in the first half. Lindelof, Matic, Rashford and Herrera were the stand out performers.’

‘TV showed Pogba’s revenge on Shelveym3 times more. Yeah, I mean, I thought Bailly’s red was Ok at first glance last game, but I counted three worse from Newcastle (Lascelles twice and Shelvey).’

‘8 home defeats for Newcastle United.’

‘Under Jose this game ends 0-0 or 1-0 Newcastle guaranteed. He’s never won at St James’ Park.’

‘Great result. Feck you Newcastle.’

 ‘Bye bye barcodes.’

‘Lascelles in the first half and Shelvey in the second half. Both were red card offenses, not sure how Newcastle ended the game with 11 men. The ref was a fecking joke.’

‘We were playing the ref and the crowd as well last night, not an easy game at all but we managed the game brilliantly.’

‘Newcastle worked hard, the ref was shambles and yet we kept playing our game. SAF team won’t do better than that in similar conditions.’

‘Do you know that Chelsea, Arsenal, Man City and Tottenham all won against Newcastle with just a 2-1 scoreline? We won 2-0 and some people are still not happy.’

‘Yeah. People here are being overly critical. Like we are supposed to steamroll them. This was a very good performance in my opinion, given the context of the game.’

‘That felt more like United to me. Yes it was nice hammering Cardiff etc but this is our bread and butter. Away to a Newcastle team that was set up to disrupt and frustrate and kick us and we kept professional and came away with the win. This was more like the Utd of old.’

‘Although Newcastle are a stubborn squad with 9 defenders, we struggled to make runs into channels and trying to be more mobile without the ball.

How Shelvey stayed on was beyond me, what a horrible disrespectful tackle. We get it, you’re a wannabe hard man but that was diagusting, imagine how Keane would have reacted to that?

Lascelles, another dirty beggar who, I thought, could have gone on another day.

Finally, Pogba played really well when he got a chance to keep on his feet after all the hacking.’

‘I think last night’s result and performance was actually the most satisfying under OGS, because it felt like the first time we were really challenged. It is of course nice to see us play free flowing attacking football, but getting the results against tough sides that really dig in is just as important. Getting the three points and the clean sheet, when Newcastle tried to kick us out of the game felt great!

If only Pogba had scored his chance in the end – that would have been the perfect “f…k you” to Shelvey.’

‘I thought Yedlin had a really good game for them up against Martial… I rate him a fair bit to be honest.

I’d maybe have him here.’

‘3 pts from a difficult game against a very well organized team.

That said if I was a Geordie I’d be fuming after seeing my team, at home, put in such a defensive display.

Benitez deserves a rocket up his arse after playing with those tactics in front of his own fans.’

‘Rafa has a first XI assembled with 40 million pounds against a high flying inform Manchester United that are pressing and playing with freedom and deadlyness.

He can’t go toe to toe with that and I don’t think the Newcastle fans disagree.

They are fighting for survival and would have bit off an arm for a point in this game I think. Small victory only having a – 2 hit to their GD.’

‘Agreed, Not much more Benitez can really be doing with the squad he has at his disposal.

I reckon if we had still been manged by Jose, his approach yesterday would have been enough to get them at least a point.

Have to feel sorry for Newcastle fans sometimes… they’re a huge club that just continually get shafted by their of an owner.’

‘What is Ashley’s end game. Surely he understands staying in the Epl requires investment. Keeps asking for miracles every season from Rafa.’

‘Apart from his rash challenge on Pogba, I was a bit alarmed at how much time on the ball Shelvey was getting when he came on. He has played something like 30 mins football since last Nov I believe the commentator said. He cut us open with that one pass and then had a decent shot himself. That’s with us playing 2 defence minded mids against someone who clearly couldn’t be match fit.Maybe nitpicking, but against better teams ie Spurs that could be harmful.’

‘Newcastle are a mess but it’s still a satisfying win. We ground it out against a side that took a 0-2 lead on us at Old Trafford earlier in the season.’

‘There was only really one time when I was concerned in this game when calamity Jones showed his worst and best (giving the ball away and then a great recovery tackle). I may have forgotten an incident but the rest of the shots were speculative or from difficult angles.’

‘Ole said this was going to be our toughest test, and he was right.

Newcastle, especially in the first half, played to their strengths. With our full backs high up the pitch, they countered with long balls into channels and got into good areas on numerous occasions. Fortunately for us, they didn’t have the attacking quality to finish their chances.

In regards to us, we started quite well. Got the ball out to Martial and got him in a few 1v1 situations and had some decent interplay in and around the box but didn’t come to much.

Second half we had more control of the game and controlled Newcastle’s counters a bit better, but we still struggled to break them down.

Thankfully, a mistake from Newcastle’s keeper and great reactions from Lukaku, gave us the lead.

At 1-0, Newcastle had to push for the goal and were vulnerable on the counter, which is where our second goal came from, courtesy of Rashford.

All in all, it wasn’t a great game, but we got the win and more importantly kept a clean sheet.’

‘Gotta say, Newcastle are the most defensive team we’ve played against this season. They just tried to suck the life and soul out of the match.

Ashley’s really done a number on that club. I couldn’t be happier with getting 3 points away there, St James Park is always a rough game for us. Generally happy with what I saw, we could have had a few more but we also could’ve conceded a couple too, professional performance.’

‘Feck yes! 0-2 vs the Geordie (never easy) and three points! 4 victories! Ole’s poker! Arse and Chelskiiii, we are coming for yaaaa…’

‘Vile game against a bunch of grotty, sh..-stained Orcs and Goblins. Kept our heads, got the win. Great subs!

Feck you Benitez,

Feck you Newcastle,

Feck you Mariner.


  • Themoscow72

    Came out with the song you sad Geordie B******* the one that scum bag Andy Cole sang. The mancs do not like it when Liverpool sing songs about them but like to dish it out. A total disgrace they are.

    • Ken

      For once I have to fully agree with you

      • WildBill

        A broken clock is right twice a day, I agree also.

        Judging by how many fecks there was in that little montage it must have been the Dublin branch posting mostly. The ‘What other fans are saying’ segments on the mag are usually a waste of life and these are especially bad. The league of nations fanbase, I sat amongst them last season at our game at old Trafford, totally eye opener if anyone thinks it’s a myth. The only people at the ground with Manchester accents were the stewards……glory hunters, they’ll never have the love for a club that we have. Not worth bothering with.

    • Toon Arnie

      Fraud. No going back now.

    • James

      One of the few things you said that I agree with

    • Big Hairy Man

      Not often I agree with you but this time you got it spot on.

    • Wezza

      What I hate and always have is that they sing their version of OUR Blaydon Races song. A disgrace and pure scum.

  • Dillon Tovak

    It’s funny how they seem to think playing them is our cup final 😂
    I fear spurs more than Man U and have done for years.
    Their bitterness is also amusing, they are aware they beat us to the title and whilst Shearer turned them down they signed Yorke, Sheringham, their current manager, Saha, Van Nistelrooy and many many more who scored bags of goals for them.
    Odd bunch 🤪

  • Billmag

    Dislike that lot with a vengeance always have done and always will.

  • Paul Cannell

    I see from that picture Mick Hucknall has cut his horrendous hair.
    Boot time it was minging, just like their glory hunter fans.

  • Mike

    Nice comments from London manc sup port and prawn Sarn brigade . Scum

  • East Durham Mag

    Typical ManUre supporters on the most part. So precious and full of schitt. How I hate Manchester United.

  • Kenny

    How much longer are the fans going to put up with the garbage Newcastle dish up every single match. the players look shot & to expect miracles off Shelvey after being out for so long & is way short of fitness is crazy.
    Rafa`s fighting a losing battle trying to keep us up with that squad.
    Newcastle can`t string 2 passes together & if by chance an opportunity to score arises there isn`t the quality to put it away.
    we don`t lose so many games at home because of the supporters, we lose them because the squads krap.
    the protests & boycott were starting to have an effect on the Rat then it`s all called off.

    • KennySamsung

      Very frustrating, keep ya chin up Kenny it’s going to be a bumpy ride but keep faith in this beautiful club minus Ashley.

  • robbersdog

    ‘Vile game against a bunch of grotty, sh..-stained Orcs and Goblins.’

    And that’s just the owner and the chief executive.

    • KennySamsung

      They got that bit right 🤣

  • Geordiegiants

    A simple reply to any Manchester spectator is this. “WERE YOU BORN IN MANCHESTER?”

  • Belfast Ali

    I grew up with so many manure fans and came to the conclusion a long time ago, that to support them, you had to be either brain dead or seriously arrogant.
    Nowadays I think they are both!
    I despise them more the older I get.

    • Albert Stubbins

      keep the faith mate- we’re built of sterner stuff than the plastics!!

  • Leicester Mag

    Don’t frankly care about the views of Manc fans or any other for that matter. What I care about is inevitability of it all. Last night was on a par with a training ground routine attackers vs defenders. What beyond blind faith drags people to watch this? That we are reduced to this to avoid a paggering is sickening

    • KennySamsung

      It’s as if we have nothing to support anymore, remembering that nothing lasts forever enables me to accept the situation because I will never release my grip on my bit of this club.

      It’s probably like living under a dictatorship where you cannot think anything except what you are told to think. If you allow this to get to you (generally speaking) he wins.

  • KennySamsung

    Manure fans have no true identity, a few thousands true supporters with the rest coming from Torquay, Cambridge, Wrexham, Bognor, Westminster, Belfast, Tunbridge Wells, Hereford and Melton Mowbray.

  • Ba ba.

    “Orcs and goblins” 😂 😂
    Obviously doesn’t get oot much.

  • Albert Stubbins

    Still obsessed with big Al? big club my a***

  • wheyayeman

    So Mr Porter….Are you able to select text using ‘ctrl’ and ‘c’ then paste said text ? “Yes Sir I think I am able to perform this as requested”. Good. And are you able to copy the text “Interesting comments from ‘insert club’s’ fans” and use this text to head your article? “Yes I believe I can do that Sir.” Excellent Mr Porter you are now ready to be a sports writer for The Mag.

  • Scottie Chugger Dearden

    I love watching Man Utd ploughing millions into nothing, the only thing they are good at nowadays.