Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!


Controversial Newcastle United incident picked out by Sky Sports as blatant decision VAR would have overturned

3 years ago

With VAR now set to finally be brought in next season, Sky Sports have picked out the most blatant examples of decisions this season that would have been overturned.

In their shortlist is the game at Old Trafford on 6 October 2018.

Newcastle cruising at 2-0 up and as obvious a penalty you could hope to see, as Ashley Young raised his arm and stopped Jonjo Shelvey’s free-kick from 10 yards away heading into the box.

The failure to give that opportunity for a surely winning 3-0 lead, made all the worse, by the fact that a week earlier Newcastle had been punished with a penalty and opening goal when DeAndre Yedlin had the ball blasted at him from only a yard.

Sky Sports:

Video assistant referees are coming to the Premier League next season – but which key decisions this term would have been overturned if the officials were permitted to check a replay?

Manchester United 3-2 Newcastle – Young handball?

‘Manchester United pulled off a thrilling – and much-needed – comeback win over Newcastle in October – but should the visitors have been awarded a penalty when they were 2-0 up at Old Trafford?

‘Jonjo Shelvey’s free-kick hit Ashley Young’s arm in the box as he attempted to block it – but referee Anthony Taylor awarded a goal-kick when the ball went out of play rather than a penalty. Could United have come back from three goals down?’

Back in October in the aftermath of the Old Trafford match, former top ref Dermot Gallagher had this to say:


“With Newcastle 2-0 up at Old Trafford, Jonjo Shelvey whips a free-kick into the box that hits Ashley Young’s arm as he goes to block it.

“Referee Anthony Taylor incorrectly awards a goal-kick and waves away penalty appeals.”

Dermot Gallagher verdict:

“Wrong call, it’s a clear penalty.”

Dermot Gallagher says:

 “It raises an interesting point.

“The referees are going to have to think about where to stand for a free-kick.

“His priority is what is going on in the box – is there going to be a foul?

“I think the learning point is to try and find a different angle so you can see both the free-kick and what’s going on in the box.”

The bottom line surely is that it has become increasingly ridiculous, that everybody watching on TV sees decisions that are so blatantly wrong and it brings the game into disrepute when the match officials get it wrong and don’t get the help to put it wrong.

Introducing VAR is hardly controversial seen as it is already used in the German, French, Italian and Spanish top tiers, as well as at the World Cup finals earlier this year.

A bit embarrassing really that the Premier League has dragged its heels.

That Newcastle game at Man Utd made all the worse when the Premier League once again allowed Anthony Taylor to referee one of their matches, despite him living only a few miles from Old Trafford.


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2021 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks