The results of the Newcastle v Nottingham Forest player ratings by fans.

Always interesting to see what supporters have collectively made of the latest performance, when using our interactive ratings system.

Each player marked out of 10 and the averages below.

Wednesday night was a shocker and I think these ratings from fans fairly reflect that.

The top rating is actually given to somebody who was only on the pitch for the final eight minutes of the normal 90. Salomon Rondon (6.3) came on and showed a bit of purpose, which was more than pretty much anybody else had done, then scored a very good goal.

Of the starters, Federico Fernandez (5.1) top scores and did his best to hold the defence together. As an Argentine international and Premier League regular, he looks what he is, a dependable tried and tested defender who will do ok. He was subbed before that late shambles of the final two goals occurred.

After that, only three others of the starting eleven score 4.0 or higher, with the inexperienced younger players Longstaff (4.8) and Sterry (4.5) sticking to their tasks in difficult circumstances. Joselu (4.1) the other one, he have plenty of effort and had one header that maybe he could have done better with, but the service to him was atrocious.

At the very lowest end of things, Kenedy (1.8) had a very similar experience to what happened at Cardiff, regularly losing the ball and nothing going right when trying to go forward. Was at fault for the first and third goals.

Christian Atsu (2.2) is showing absolutely nothing this season so far and gave Newcastle no help going forward, needs to step it up.

The other five starters were poor to below average, with Karl Darlow very lucky to get away with a couple of poor attempts to deal with crosses and shots. Schar (3.8) struggling at the back, Ki (3.8) running around a lot in midfield but getting nowhere, Muto (3.7) a similar story up front. Ciaran Clark (3.1) looking uncomfortable as he ended up playing kind of left-back for much of the game.

All in all, a desperate picture of a team that played without inspiration or any real purpose, fringe players doing nothing to convince they should be starting in the Premier League.

Below are the ratings as voted by Newcastle fans up to 6am Friday:

newcastle v nottingham forest player ratings

If you haven’t already put in your Newcastle v Nottingham Forest player ratings, go HERE and you can still input your own marks out of 10 for each player, then check back later to see whether the overall interactive ratings have changed for the team as more fans vote.

Stats from BBC Sport:

Nottingham Forest 3 Newcastle United 1

Goals

Newcastle: Rondon 90+2

Forest: Murphy 2, Cash 90+4, Dias 90+7

Possession was Forest 46% Newcastle 54%

Total shots were  Forest 11 Newcastle 10

Shots on target were Forest 7 Newcastle 1

Corners were  Forest 5 Newcastle 3

Referee: Jeremy Simpson

Crowd: 13,942 (3,000 Newcastle)

Newcastle United:

Darlow, Sterry,  Schar, Fernandez (Perez 69), Clark, Kenedy, Atsu, Ki, Longstaff, Muto (Murphy 77), Joselu (Rondon 82)

Unused Subs:

Elliot, Diame, Yedlin, Dummett



  • Kenny

    Apart from Rondon I wouldn’t give any player a rating above 4, the new lads are what they are, shirt fillers. £9m for a Japanese striker who looks well out of his depth and we have £30m plus on the bench and not one of them is worth a nut.
    Fat 🐀 Rat, out.

    • Paul Patterson

      That’s what happens when the managers list of players is turned upside down and then worked through. You get the third or fourth choice options . .

      • mentalman

        their still rafa’s choices and there were better options available for the money spent

    • Wor Lass

      It`s maybe a bit early to judge Muto. He seems a bit lightweight but might work well off Rondon.

  • DeadToiler

    I don’t think these rating exercises have any value at all. Like surveys they just give another platform for the moaners. The important questions are:
    Where they really trying?
    and
    Are they happy to be out of this cup?
    It seems as though this competition was seen as a contractual obligation (suggested previously on this forum) and not a chance to win something or at least have a go.

    • mentalman

      The only 3 who looked like they were trying were sterry, longstaff and fernandez the rest didn’t take their opportunity to try and show they should be part of the first team