Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!


Ratings system brought into disrepute with these marks for Newcastle players

4 years ago

The Newcastle players were a sorry sight as they left the pitch after that 3-0 home humiliation by Watford.

A three goal defeat that could have been far far worse if the visitors had taken a few more of the clear chances to come their way.

Not really any positives in the NUFC ranks, although Jacob Murphy was the best of a bad bunch and is hinting now at why Rafa Benitez was willing to make the winger his biggest summer signing, when using the limited funds available in the close season.

Our fan ratings for the Newcastle players reflected the performance, thousands of supporter votes coming together to give Jacob Murphy 5.6 out of 10, right down to Joselu on 1.9.

However, elsewhere there has been some slightly bemusing values given to the displays of certain Newcastle players at the weekend.

The team has been drawn from the players who were included in the 20 Premier League clubs who played this Saturday and Sunday.

The  system automatically analyses every match in all the major European Leagues, with over 200 raw statistics used to calculate each player’s ratings and are then weighted according to influence in the game – taking into account the area of the pitch and its outcome for each important event.

That is the theory anyway…This system is used by numerous sections of the football industry; including media, bookmakers and clubs themselves in evaluating performances.

These are the ratings out of 10 that the WhoScored system gave after Newcastle 0 Watford 3:

5.8 Elliot

6.6 Yedlin

7.9 Lejeune

6.3 Clark

6.1 Manquillo

6.1 Ritchie

5.8 Selvey

6.5 Diame

6.6 Murphy

6.0 Gayle

7.0 Joselu

Gomes 7.7, Mariappa 7.5, Kabasele 7.7, Britos 6.9, Femenia 7.1, Hughes 8.2, Doucoure 7.2, Cleverley 7.7, Zeegelaar 8.6, Richarlison 8.3, Gray 7.1

Amazingly, Florian Lejeune is not only rated Newcastle’s best performer, he actually makes the WhoScored Premier League team of the weekend, when compared to central defenders for all other 19 teams.

I think he has ability but the Frenchman was really poor on Saturday and the 3.7 rating (see all fan ratings from Saturday HERE) was a lot closer to the mark than making him one of teh Premier League players of the week!

How Lejeune is even rated above all the Watford defenders is bizarre enough.

Just when you think the WhoScored rating system couldn’t fall further into disrepute, Joselu gets 7.0 and rated Newcastle’s second best player against Watford.

Statistics/automatic systems are all very well but you also need to incorporate what you see with your own eyes…


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2022 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks