In advance of West Ham on Monday here are the Newcastle fans ratings for each United player so far this season.
After every Newcastle game we ask supporters to give marks out of 10 for every player, then from the thousands who vote we get definitive ratings using our interactive feature.
Taking the first four Premier League matches, we have added all the marks together and came out with an average for each player who has started at least one league game.
We haven’t included ratings for substitutes as if they come on late in the match they will generally get a low mark as they will have had little chance to influence the game.
As you can see, Steven Taylor and Ayoze Perez are at the top, but they owe that from just one start against Manchester United when the whole team were given a collective pat on the back in the ratings.
When it comes to players who have started at least two games, you have Chancel Mbemba and Tim Krul at the top, both of them showing consistency over four starting line-ups each.
Thauvin got a decent mark for his part in the battling display v Arsenal, whilst Colback and Anita have got steady marks reflecting no frills but ok showings from them.
In contrast, Coloccini got 7.8 and 8.8 v Arsenal and Man Utd, whilst only 2.8 and 5.6 v Swansea.
At the other end of things, Janmaat and Obertan are struggling, with the Dutch player’s red card at Swansea leading to a very low 1.6 for that game, plus he hasn’t looked at his best in others.