I was checking something the other day and happened to have a look at the Newcastle v Liverpool match in December 2010, Alan Pardew’s first match in charge.

I saw the line up and was thinking, surely Adam Campbell couldn’t have been involved then….!

Turns out Sol Campbell played that day, doubt I would have guessed that in a million years. Guess Coloccini must have been injured.

The team that beat Liverpool 3-1 on Saturday 11th December 2010:

Krul, Simpson, Steven Taylor, Campbell, Enrique, Barton, Nolan, Tiote, Jonas, Shola Ameobi, Carroll

Kevin Nolan opened the scoring before Sol Campbell gifted Dirk Kuyt the equaliser, before Barton and Carroll added on each to give Pardew a winning start.

(To feature like Sam, send in your articles for our website to [email protected] – all views are the author’s own etc etc)

Wayne Routledge, Alan Smith and Nile Ranger came on as subs and indeed Ranger helped to create the second goal by making a nuisance of himself (neither the first or the last time that has happened…).

I then started to compare that team on Alan Pardew’s first day, with the following eleven who played against Manchester United last week:

Krul, Janmaat, Coloccini, Williamson, Ryan Taylor, Obertan, Sissoko, Abeid, Sammy Ameobi, Riviere, Cisse

I have to say that the biggest difference is the midfield, I know Colback was suspended in that last game but I reckon that Barton, Nolan, Jonas and Tiote (2010 vintage) would have wiped the floor with Obertan, Sissoko, Abeid and Sammy Ameobi.

Taking the twenty two players from the two starting elevens, I would pick this eleven:

Krul, Janmaat, Coloccini, Steven Taylor, Enrique, Barton, Tiote, Sissoko, Jonas, Cisse, Carroll

When Alan Pardew walked out on the club and joined Crystal Palace, he claimed the team had moved on from when he first arrived.

Looking at the respective line-ups I think it is all but impossible to judge one better than the other, what I do think is clear though is that any progress on over four years is marginal at best.


  • jimblag

    true true

  • DownUnderMag

    Yup, doesn’t look like it’s move on to me.  Sidewards if not backwards.  Would still love to see Barton, Nolan, Carroll and Enrique in a Black n Whit shirt.  My mind isn’t made up on Tiote, in his first two seasons, without a doubt he was immense….lately though he just seems like a liability – be it he is out of form or just has his mind elsewhere who knows, but he is a shadow of his former self.

  • Nicolaus Copernicus

    Interesting piece of reminiscence. By the time the 2010 – 2011 season came along, Ashley had probably formulated his mid-table mediocrity strategy, so it’s little wonder we are comparing one ordinary team from back then with the ordinary team we have today.