After the final whistle at St. James’ Park on Sunday we asked you for your Newcastle v Stoke player ratings.

Supporters rated all fourteen players used and from that there is generated the overall supporter marks for every player.

Below we have produced the results of  the fan ratings showing by noon on Monday.

As you can see, Remy Cabella (along with Jack Colback) has the highest rating, while Mike Williamson is rock bottom.

newcastle v stoke player ratingsIf you haven’t already put in your player ratings for Newcastle against Stoke, go HERE and you can still input your own marks out of 10 for each player, then check back to see whether the overall interactive ratings change for the team.

This is just one of the many great new features we are implementing on our new look website.

Christmas Gifts - shop.themag.co.uk


  • supermacsnewname

    seems a bit low for Krull – but imagine what Perez would do with decent support
    but tell me, is there a single person in this universe that knows what he’s talking about who does not know we desperately need a PL quality centre half and striker?
    still at least we have the battle of the giants to look forward to – Pardew v Carver ! We live in exciting times!

  • Steve1221

    Harsh on Obertan who made a big difference when he came on, even made a couple of good tackles chasing back which isn’t like him. Just a shame he panicked when through on goal.

  • Maximus Moose

    supermacsnewname Dumb v Dumber

  • Kev82

    Good pull back for the goal but other than that it was Obertan of old, headless chicken and giving the ball away cheaply, he was still far more effective than the waste of space on the other wing who was kept on far too long.

  • Philippines

    I suggest that the objective view of some folks is reflected in the fact that Mehdi, who only played 7 minutes, is rated higher than Williamson. Nice to see fair and balanced assessments.