We want all fans to give us your Man City v Newcastle player ratings using our new interactive system.

Please rate all fourteen players used and from that there will be generated the overall supporter marks for every player.

Plus you can keep checking back to see how all the players are doing, as the overall ratings are instantly updated as people input their marks out of 10.

This is just one of the many great new features we are implementing on our new look website.

Mark the players now with your ratings.


  • toonterrier

    After this performance what the players need is some time off to charge their batteries. What Charva and his backroom staff need is a change of scenery well away from Newcastle. Luckily Man City weren’t at their best otherwise it could well have been a double figure defeat.

  • LeazesEnder

    toonterrier they’ve just come back from Dubai…warm weather training

  • The trooper

    Tongue in cheek I think was meant. Shocking display again

  • alreet

    Christ. We were only in europe 2 seasons ago. Rubbing shoulders with benfica. Oh dear where next?? Dagenham or yeoviĺl?

  • john oneil

    Wonder what Charva’so game plan was…..?

  • scotty63

    john oneil It worked man, without the plan goodness knows how many it could have been. Another feather in Honest John’s cap.

  • Greggy164

    john oneil   What would you do?

    I would play a 4-1-3-2 like I do on FM. If I go a goal down I change it to a 4-3-1-2 All out attack

  • Greggy164

    alreet  Nothing to do wi Jesus. Leave him oot of it

  • grahame49

    To be honest my mind screams don’t go alas my heart says love has to have no conditions so I’m there on sat and the wed after. Its crap but our crap this deluded fan wants nothing but a team who plays with the pride I have as a fan nowt more

  • Jimmywayhay

    Why isn’t there an X available ,this should be X rated

  • Toon Magpie

    Head coach rating – zero.

  • Greggy164

    grahame49  Its tough when theres no sign of things getting better

  • Greggy164

    Toon Magpie  Gie me the job!!  Won the big cup 3 times 0n the bounce wi Rangers. Legend

  • Greggy164

    Toon Magpie  Built the team using the best from the youth team and a couple of shrewd signings. They even named a stand after me. lol

  • supermacsnewname

    beam me up scotty – no sign of intelegent life detected or leader identified, natives appear to wander about aimlesly without any organisation, motivation or objective
    a sad case – logic dictates that with such rich resouces a great culture should flourish

  • Conman

    You can’t complain Grahame then. What actual enjoyment are you getting. We need masses to walk and you are part of the problem I’m afraid. Blind loyalty.

  • mentalman

    Bit harsh giving gouff and Williamson lower scores than haidara!

  • GToon

    Greggy164 john oneil Play Anita to pick up Silva and Sissoko to match up against Toure. Then actually get Williamson to man mark one of their players. That would be a start.

  • PhilYare

    what do you have to do to get 1 of of 10? if that means you’ve got to do 10% things right then i simply cant give most of the players any mark

  • Toonbadger

    mentalman  HOW??????

  • Toonbadger

    Toon Magpie  Minus zero

  • Toonbadger

    grahame49  MUG

  • DZA187

    toonterrier I would of had the players in on sunday training and not giving them a day off. Clueless JC strikes again, the guy is a twit.

  • mentalman

    Haidara offered nothing in defence or going forward and hasn’t for a few games now, he looked like he’d never played a game of football before. Williamson was partly at fault for the 1st goal but haidara was at fault with at least 2. Gouff tried when out of position

  • SteveThomson

    Sorry but Haidara was lucky to get  a rating of 1 from  me. He has NEVER been able to defend. 
    Despite the all round ineptitude of the whole team, the most depressing aspect was the lack of effort. Nobody seemed interested in marking a man or closing City players down. If we had 3- 4 points less I would say that we would be favourites to be relegated