Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!

Tyne Talk

Some Players Are More Purple Than Others

8 years ago

Another ‘winnable’ game, another defeat. What went wrong – not enough quality, not enough commitment, not enough strength in depth?

Derek Llambias talked of Newcastle United being in a position where we can only accommodate eleven purple (star) players, specifically naming Vurnon Anita as one of those eleven in our current squad.

By my mathematics that meant against Southampton we had eight purples (Krul, Steven Taylor, Santon, Anita, Tiote, Jonas, Ba, Cisse) on the pitch, with only Cabaye, Coloccini and Ben Arfa missing.

Unfortunately, I think we are finding out that maybe some players are a touch more purple than others.

The fact Fabricio Coloccini is our captain speaks for itself when it comes to what he gives the team, while sadly the absence of Cabaye and Ben Arfa reminds us how there is almost a  total absence of real quality creativity in the rest of the squad.

I think when it comes down to the real top quality in the squad I would maybe say we have six (deep?) purples with the other three being Demba Ba who has fed off mainly scraps this season yet is still second top scorer in the Premier League, while when he’s on his game Cheick Tiote is real quality in terms of breaking up play but not creating, while Tim Krul is having one of those periods when he is drifting below his usual total reliability and getting punished for every mistake.

If we have these six on the pitch together then they give the team a real solid spine with Hatem Ben Arfa the enigmatic wildcard.

As we are now finding out, there is a big difference in missing a few first team players and a situation where your real quality is not available, especially when their replacements are way below the standard needed.

Send in your letters/articles to [email protected]

Buy a copy of the new issue of our magazine for only £3 online HERE, it includes interviews with Ryan Taylor and Supermac as well as all the usual features and columnists. You can also buy Subscriptions online HERE, prices starting from £23, the perfect Christmas present. The magazine for the good AND the bad times.



If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2021 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks