Get your daily update and weekly newsletter by signing up today!


Demba Ba Value Set Higher Than Andy Carroll’s

9 years ago

With the relative merits of Demba Ba and Andy Carroll a big talking point at the moment, interesting to see the Daily Telegraph getting in on the act.

Their Fantasy Football competition has Demba Ba valued at £6m in their ratings, compared to Andy Carroll lagging behind on £5.8m, perhaps giving extra credence to any possible swap deal involving cash PLUS Carroll for Ba!

At times Newcastle United did indeed play some fantasy stuff last season but seeing a Fantasy Football competition for the coming season it got me thinking…

The Daily Telegraph allow you £50m to spend on your eleven players of choice and interestingly, if you wanted to buy Newcastle’s first choice eleven from last season you would still have over £6m change, as combined they would set you back £43.7m.

As a comparison, it would set you back the following for our competitors – Everton (£42.6m), Liverpool (£44.9m), Spurs (£48.4m) and with Manchester City you would have to compromise somewhere as their eleven most valued players come out at £53.2m according to the Telegraph.

Of course these figures are all to fit in with the Telegraph’s budget per team of £50m and don’t equal ‘real’ values but the amounts are relative in competing players, so for example it is interesting/amusing that they rate Liverpool’s most valuable eleven above Newcastle’s.

The values attached for the purposes of Fantasy Football for the Newcastle players were;

Krul £3.5m, Simpson £3.5m, Coloccini £3.8m, Steven Taylor £3.1m, Santon £3.2m, Ben Arfa £3.8m, Tiote £3.2m, Cabaye £4.2m, Jonas £4m, Ba £6m, Cisse £6.4m

If Newcastle’s eleven players above were said to have a total value of £50m, this is how I would carve up their relative values to the club/team – that is real value to the team rather than to get Fantasy League points;

Krul £5.5m, Simpson £2.5m, Coloccini £5m, Steven Taylor £4m, Santon £3.5m, Ben Ara £4.5m, Tiote £5m, Cabaye £5m, Jonas £4m, Ba £5m, Cisse £6m

If you would like to feature like Alan Clay on our/your website, get writing. Send in your articles and we’ll put them up on the website for everybody to enjoy. Get writing!


If you would like to feature on The Mag, submit your article to [email protected]

Have your say

© 2021 The Mag. All Rights Reserved. Design & Build by Mediaworks