Leaving Newcastle United, never an option for the supporters but many players, for many different reasons, have left over the years.

Yesterday I looked at players such as Woodgate, Dyer, Jenas and others (‘Is The Grass Ever Greener When Players Leave Newcastle United?’) who looked to ‘better’ themselves by moving away from St.James’ Park, today I’m looking at some other interesting cases.

Shay Given – A loyal servant to Newcastle for twelve years, Given decided that for the sake of his career he would move to Man.City in January 2009. In hindsight however, I bet Shay wished he hadn’t, as no sooner had he arrived than he found that his position was firmly on the substitute’s bench due to the emergence of current England number one, Joe Hart.

Registering 0 appearances in his second full season at Eastlands, Given moved to Aston Villa in the summer of 2011 and spent last season fighting off the threat of relegation, whilst his former employers finished 5th.

Charles N’Zogbia – Yet another talented Newcastle youngster who had the wrong attitude and took his position for granted. He performed well and was a skilful talent no doubt, however the word that springs to most Newcastle fans’ mind regarding ‘Zog’ is petulance. Frequently linking himself with moves to ‘bigger’ clubs which never transpired, N’Zogbia eventually got his wish as a result of Joe Kinnear’s infamous ‘insomnia’ incident in January 2009.

However, the move that he had seemed so eager to push for ended with him going to Wigan, where he spent two and a half seasons playing for a relegation threatened club. A move to Aston Villa followed in the summer of 2011, where he spent last season once more fighting relegation, evidence that his career has suffered as a result of leaving Tyneside.

Habib Beye – Signed for £2million in the summer of 2007, Beye had a tremendous first season, picking up Newcastle’s player of the year – leading Kevin Keegan to call him one of the best right-backs in the division. Despite this though, Beye left after Newcastle’s relegation in the summer of 2009 to join Aston Villa.

Since moving however, his career has been nothing short of a disaster. At Villa, Beye made just 9 appearances in 2 years and was deemed surplus to requirements. Worse was to follow though, as Beye has since signed for Doncaster Rovers and was part of their relegation from the Championship last season, meaning will be lining up for them in League One next year in an incredible turn of fortunes.

Michael Owen – Club record signing for £16million in the summer of 2005 and I would suggest, pound for pound, possibly Newcastle’s worst ever signing. During his four years on Tyneside, Owen spent the majority out injured and proved a feckless captain in Newcastle’s relegation campaign. What’s more, even though he was one of the chief culprits for the drop into the Championship, Owen couldn’t jump ship quick enough with a surprising move to Man.Utd in the summer of 2009. Since then however, Owen has got more used to the feeling of sitting on the bench rather than kicking a football, typified by his 1 appearance last season.

Despite this though, during the epic final day showdown of last season’s Premier League, when the Man.United game had finished but the City one was still ongoing and the destination of the title still unknown.  Owen comically, who hadn’t played that day, was proudly there in his full kit, shinpads and all,  ready to join in the celebrations of a title that he would have had literally nothing to do with. Thankfully however, Aguero scored to give the title to City and Owen has since been released.

Obafemi Martins – A striker who rose to prominence with Inter Milan and was signed for £10million in the summer of 2006 as a response to Alan Shearer’s retirement. Somewhat erratic and far from prolific, Martins was nonetheless a talented footballer capable of the superb, such as his goal against Tottenham in the 2006/2007 season at White Hart Lane.

Was one of a number of players to leave Newcastle after their relegation and ended up signing for Wolfsburg in Germany. After which Martins signed for Russian club Rubin Kazan and having failed to settle there went on loan to Birmingham City in 2011, however he failed to earn a permanent deal at St.Andrews illustrating how his career has stuttered since leaving.

Sebastien Bassong –  An unknown quantity who signed off the back of a trial in the summer of 2008, Bassong went from strength to strength during the 2008/2009 season, eventually picking up Newcastle’s player of the year award.

Despite this however, after just one season on Tyneside Bassong moved to Spurs after Newcastle’s relegation in the summer of 2009. Since moving however, he has never been first choice at the Lane and ended up being sent out on loan to relegated Wolves last season.


James Milner – The only possible success I can find, Milner was a strong and youthful player on Tyneside with a lot of talent and his selling to Aston Villa on the final day of the 2008 summer transfer window contributed to Kevin Keegan’s resignation. At Villa, Milner was part of a set-up which challenged for Champions League football and he has since signed for Man.City, where he won the Premiership title last season. Therefore perhaps Milner is the only player I can find that has succeeded by leaving Newcastle to a ‘bigger’ club in the last decade or so.

Therefore, the overwhelming consensus as illustrated by Enrique, Carroll and Barton this season and all these examples before them is that on the whole, the grass is never greener when you leave Newcastle. Accordingly, the message to Newcastle’s current players must be…don’t leave!

Why not start a 10 issue Mag subscription with the superb new summer special – every month a new issue direct to your door. Subscribe online here

Buy a single copy of the summer special online here in The Mag Shop available for worldwide delivery.

A bumper 60 page issue of classic Newcastle United coverage with a European flavouring!

  • Steve Hanley

    It all depends on how you’re measuring success. Bellamy, Enrique, Carroll. All have a medal to show for this season and as much as it pains me to say it. That’s something they wouldn’t have got here. Going back a bit further Andy Cole, Sir Les, Ginola, Hamman. All picked up medals of varying degrees when they left here

    • GeordieBen

      As did Martins for Birmingham season before… somehow

  • Jamesmurphyvarley

    If you leave Newcastle you turn out rubbish

  • Micky_porter1989

    scott parker

  • Guy Maxwell

    For someone like Ba or Ben Arfa the temptation to move on must be strong when the likes of Paris (“We’re Really Rich Now”) Saint-Germain or Chelsea come calling, but the question that any player should always ask themselves is whether they are happy to pick up medals as a bit part squad member (earling shed loads) or whether they want to be a key player in a team at a slightly lower level.  Footballers always contradict themselves on that question “I want to be playing, oh hang on, how much, adios!”.

    As things stand I personally suspect that the majority of our squad will stay this summer as the club is on the up.  Failure to build on that and things will be very different come 2013.

    As for Parker, would you say that he is is a success?  He was captain of a team that go relegated.  His only “honour” is still a the Newcastle captain that liften the Intertoto Cup, sure he has won individual awards and done well, but I’m not sure you would call his career (pre, during or post) a success.

    • Lee Cowan1979

      Scott Parker:-  14 england caps since leaving us and Football Writers player of the year season before last, cant really blame him for the west ham relegation, hence the prestigious award bestowed on him, nar mate total failure,

  • In the defence of Shay Given he was absolutely right to leave Newcastle at the time. We were an absolute mess and I don’t buy the excuse some people offer (that he left when we needed him most). He is a top class goalkeeper and seemed certain to leave at various times before that. A great player and someone who genuinely cared I think but he had to leave when he did.

  • Alex

    In terms of a good, solid career to look back on, I’d say that Steve Watson and Aaron Hughes are others who weren’t shamed by leaving (somewhat reluctantly) the Toon.