Newcastle v Sunderland – Who Are The Transfer Winners?

pardewoneill1Alan Pardew and Martin O’Neill have traded (verbal) blows on the touchline but who will prove the winner in the toe to toe transfer contest?

While spending was kept to a minimum at St.James’ Park in the summer, O’Neill was given some £25m to bring in Steven Fletcher and Adam Johnson, two players who every other Premier League manager was well aware of. While Sunderland have also dipped into the overseas markets, their main purchase again was homegrown (as a Geordie!) Danny Graham for a fee of around £5m, again a player that was well know to everybody in England.

(To feature like Joe, send in your letters/articles for the magazine/website to contribute@themag.co.uk)

In contrast, Newcastle have continued their raiding of Ligue 1 and have added Mapou, Sissoko, Haidara, Gouffron and Debuchy for some £18m, three of them already French internationals. These were added to the stellar signings of Ben Arfa and Cabaye who are reported to have cost anything up to £11m for the pair.

So for rough figures you could say that Martin O’Neill has brought in three proven Premiership players for around the same as Newcastle have paid for five French internationals plus the youthful Haidara and Gouffran with a decent goalscoring record in France.

Sunderland may be just ahead of Newcastle in the league at the moment but who will be the transfer market winners in the end? Newcastle v Sunderland, France v England/Scotland?

I would say a fair reflection must be based on what happens next season, the anti-Newcastle faction will no doubt be hoping/praying that Newcastle’s over reliance on the French market will lead to cliques/players not settling/not enough quality French restaurants in the toon/ the step up to Premier League proving too much – and so on.

I would find it very hard to envisage Newcastle coming out on the wrong end of this contest, especially taking into account other factors.

Newcastle’s problems going into this season were not that we didn’t have decent players, it was that we had some excellent/decent players but if anybody was injured it was almost certain to lead to a massive drop in ability from their replacements. The challenge was to add quality to quality and now belatedly that appears to have happened in January, plus with real value for money.

By contrast, looking from the outside Sunderland looked to have a very mediocre team and could just about put out two different teams and you would be hard pressed to say which was better. Bringing in players who would be better than they had would hardly be difficult and so it has proved, Fletcher and Johnson proving easily to be two of Sunderland’s best players but it comes at a price by going for the obvious, even with players already proven in the Premier League at a middle of the table kind of level.

If both teams hang onto their best players then there will be only one winner but maybe that is Newcastle’s biggest weakness in the contest.

Clubs with big resources may see there is still big value in players like Cabaye, Ben Arfa, Sissoko and others, whatever prohibitive transfer fees are placed on their heads by Mike Ashley. In contrast Sunderland have already had to pay right up to the value (and beyond?) for their signings, both in terms of wages and transfer fees.

As always, the greatest threat to Newcastle United is whether there are any self-inflicted blows in the summer.

Why not celebrate Newcastle United’s resurgence with a subscription (prices from £23) to the top selling Newcastle United magazine, new issue out next Saturday. Magazines sent out all over the UK as well as every country around the world you can think of. Order NOW in our online shop .

The Mag, Issue 289, 5 April 2014, Newcastle United Magazine, NUFC

The latest issue of The Mag is available now!

Available online here in The Mag Shop and in newsagents throughout the North East for only £3!

Why not subscribe? Subscriptions start from only £23. Never miss an issue and delivery direct to your door worldwide.

Subscribe Now Buy Now

2 Responses to “Newcastle v Sunderland – Who Are The Transfer Winners?”

  1. Heaton Mick

    I’m sure some will disagree with me, but do we really need so many articles comparing/referencing those down the road?

    In the past few weeks we’ve had articles on their transfer window signings, Danny Graham’s reception in a match we weren’t involved in and the accommodation arrangements their players.

    I’m not saying it’s not good to have a bit of a laugh at them, but there’s a risk we could resort to their small town mentality if we continue to concentrate on what they’re doing.

    • mkeats

      Spot on mick. Lets leave these stupid articles out. One thing that’s always struck me about those Down the road is their ability to talk about Newcastle in most discussions that are about their own club. Lets not go down this petty road. Lets have a laugh when things aren’t going right for them but leave these types of stupid articles to the press.

×

Comments are closed.