Which Newcastle players would you keep?

This season has seen signs of promise, despite a largely poor set of results, but it has become clear that United don’t really have a squad.

A combination of younger players who maybe aren’t up to it, longstanding players who are past their sell-by date, or signings who haven’t worked out.

Newcastle are in need of a squad shake up and to start again with a core of key players.

The question is, which players should they keep and build from?

We’d like you to pick 11 players from this list of 30 who you would most like to see Newcastle keep and then add to for a real meaningful squad, to help take the club back to a position where they can compete in a meaningful way.

It doesn’t have to be a team of players, just the best eleven players Newcastle have to take us forward.

So you can have one goalkeeper, three goalkeepers or even perhaps none.

You can choose six defenders or none at all, likewise with midfielders and strikers.

So pick your 11 best Newcastle players to take the club forward and we’ll bring you the overall results later.